
Car Accident Lawsuits | New Orleans, Louisiana
What to Expect If Your Car Accident Case Goes to Trial
A plain-language guide to each stage, from preparation to the courtroom, for people who were hurt and want to know what comes next.
By Przemek Lubecki · Published November 11, 2026
A letter from an insurance company, a demand for payment, or a lawsuit you didn’t expect can leave you asking what comes next. If a car accident case goes to court, it moves through formal steps. A written complaint is filed, both sides exchange evidence, the case may be tried before a judge or jury, and a judgment is entered. An appeal may follow.
This guide walks through each step in plain language under Louisiana civil law. It explains how the process generally works, not how any one case will turn out.
Where you may be right now
This guide is for people facing a possible lawsuit or trying to understand one. You may have an insurer’s offer in hand, a demand letter, or court papers you were served with. You may also be a family member of someone who was hurt or killed, trying to learn what lies ahead. Many readers aren’t ready to hire anyone yet. They want to understand the process before they decide anything, and that’s a sensible place to start.
The steps described here apply to car accidents, truck accidents, commercial vehicle accidents, rideshare accidents, motorcycle accidents, and wrongful death claims. Each case has its own facts and parties, but the general court steps are similar.
Przemek Lubecki is the responsible lawyer for this page. American Trial Lawyer, LLC has its office in New Orleans, Louisiana. American Trial Lawyer, LLC may associate or refer a case to other law firms.
If an insurer's offer or a lawsuit has you unsure what comes next, our team in New Orleans can talk it through with you in a free, confidential consultation. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.
Most car accident claims do not reach a courtroom
Many claims are resolved through negotiation before any lawsuit is filed or before a trial begins. These talks often happen with the insurance company, through letters, demands, and counteroffers.
Insurers often prefer to settle. A jury verdict brings cost, delay, and uncertainty for both sides. A settlement avoids those by ending the dispute through agreement. A settlement is a private agreement between the parties, and a case can settle at any stage, even on the day of trial.
A case may need a courtroom when the sides can’t agree on who was at fault, what the injuries are worth, or whether the offer is fair. A disagreement on any one of those points can keep a claim moving toward court.
Is it better to settle or go to trial?
Neither option is better for every case. The right path turns on the facts of your crash, your injuries, and the offer in front of you.
Some questions to weigh with your lawyer:
- Does the offer cover your full losses, including medical care and lost income?
- Is fault disputed, and what evidence supports each side?
- How long would recovery take, and how much delay can you accept?
- How strong is the proof of your injuries?
Trial is one option among several. The decision is made with you, based on your goals and the facts. Nobody should be pushed into a courtroom or a settlement before they understand their choices.
How a car accident lawsuit begins in Orleans Parish
A lawsuit starts when the injured person, or a family in a wrongful death case, files a petition with the court. The petition is a written complaint that names the parties and states the claim.
The answer may admit or deny the allegations and raise defenses. Cases arising in Orleans Parish are filed in the courts that have authority over them there. Some cases go to federal court instead, which follows its own procedures. A plaintiff may name the at-fault driver, the vehicle’s owner, or an employer when the facts support it.
Timing matters. Filing suit in a proper court and venue interrupts the deadline to sue, and that interruption continues while the suit is pending (La. Civ. Code art. 3463). If a plaintiff abandons the suit, voluntarily dismisses it, or fails to prosecute the suit at the trial, the interruption is treated as never having occurred. A dismissal under a settlement does not count as a voluntary dismissal. For wrongful death, the right to sue prescribes one year from the death or two years from the injury, whichever is longer (La. Civ. Code art. 2315.2).

Discovery: how each side gathers evidence
Discovery is the stage where each side gets information from the other and collects its own evidence. It often takes months.
Discovery may include written questions called interrogatories, requests for documents, and requests for admission, which ask the other side to confirm facts. Depositions are sworn testimony taken outside the courtroom. Lawyers ask the questions, and a court reporter records the answers. The driver, witnesses, and treating providers may be deposed when they have relevant information.
Common evidence includes police and crash reports, photographs, vehicle data, medical records, and wage records. Louisiana law keeps crash reports confidential, and they are made available only to the parties to the crash, parents or guardians of a minor party, insurers or insurance support organizations under contract to provide claims and underwriting for a party, healthcare providers or their agents that treated a party, succession representatives and attorneys of the parties, and news-gathering organizations that request a specific crash. Upon request, they are made available within seven working days after the crash investigation is completed (La. R.S. 32:398).
If you gave a recorded or written statement after the crash, you have a right to a copy. A person who took the statement must furnish a true and complete copy within twenty days after written demand (La. R.S. 13:3732).
In a truck or commercial vehicle case, driver records may matter too. Federal rules limit how long property-carrying drivers may drive, including an 11-hour driving limit (49 CFR § 395.3). Discovery often shows where each side’s account is strong or weak.
What happens at trial
At trial, each side presents its case to a judge or a jury, and the case ends with a decision. The steps follow a set order.
Jury selection comes first when a jury is used. Each side then gives an opening statement that outlines the evidence it expects to present. Each side calls its witnesses and offers its exhibits. Witnesses take an oath, answer questions from the lawyer who called them, and then face cross-examination from the other side.
Throughout the trial, the judge rules on objections and decides which evidence may be presented. Once the evidence is in, each side gives a closing argument that ties the facts to the law. The jury, or the judge when no jury is used, then decides the case.
Witnesses describe what they saw, did, or experienced. No one can predict how a particular jury will decide a case. That uncertainty is one reason many cases settle before trial.
Not sure what your next step is?
Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.
How fault and damages are decided
The court decides who was at fault, by what percentage, and what damages apply.
Louisiana applies comparative fault. Under the current version of La. Civ. Code art. 2323, which took effect January 1, 2026, a person found 51 percent or more at fault is not entitled to recover damages under paragraph A, while paragraph C provides that, where the other fault is that of an intentional tortfeasor, the recovery of damages is not reduced. A person whose share is less than 51 percent can recover, and the damages are reduced in proportion to that person’s own negligence, unless the other fault is that of an intentional tortfeasor, in which case the claim is not reduced. The article also requires that everyone who contributed to the injury be considered, whether or not they are parties to the case.
Louisiana law also says a person whose fault causes damage must repair it (La. Civ. Code art. 2315). Damages generally fall into two groups. Economic damages include medical bills and lost income. General damages cover harms such as pain and suffering, which are harder to measure. Louisiana law leaves much discretion to the judge or jury in assessing damages in cases of offenses, quasi offenses, and quasi contracts (La. Civ. Code art. 2324.1). No one can say in advance what a judge or jury will award.
In a wrongful death case, Louisiana law lists who may sue, in order. A surviving spouse and children come first. If there is no spouse or child, the parents may sue. Then siblings, and then grandparents, depending on who survived (La. Civ. Code art. 2315.2).
After a verdict, and taking the next step
After a verdict, a party may be able to appeal. Appeals have their own deadlines and procedures, separate from the trial itself. A case can also settle at any point, including after trial begins or after a verdict.
Reading about a courtroom can be stressful, especially if you’re still recovering or grieving a loss. You don’t need to decide anything today.
Frequently asked questions
Does every car accident case go to court?
No. Many claims are resolved through settlement, and only some are filed and tried.
How long does a car accident lawsuit take?
Timing varies by case. Discovery alone can take months.
Can a family sue after a fatal crash?
Louisiana law lists which family members may bring a wrongful death claim, in a set order.
If an insurer’s offer or a lawsuit has you unsure what comes next, you don’t have to work through the courtroom steps alone. Call 855-LUBECKI for a free, confidential initial consultation with no obligation to continue. Przemek Lubecki practices with American Trial Lawyer, LLC at our New Orleans office.
How Our Firm Approaches Your Case
Personal attention from Przemek Lubecki
Przemek Lubecki is the lawyer responsible for this page and leads the work on car accident cases at American Trial Lawyer, LLC in New Orleans.
Careful preparation
We gather records, photographs, medical documentation and witness information so that every stage of the case is built on the facts.
Clear communication
We explain each decision in plain language, so you know where your case stands and what options are being considered.
Advocacy in the courtroom
We are prepared to present your case to a judge and jury with the same care we give to every stage before trial.
Talk to a Lawyer Before Speaking with an Insurer
Insurance adjusters may ask for recorded statements soon after a crash. Speaking with a lawyer first can help you understand what to say and what to hold back while your case is still being evaluated.
The Stages of a Car Accident Trial
Preparation
Pleadings are filed, evidence is exchanged, and witnesses and experts are identified before the trial date is set.
Jury Selection
The court and the parties question potential jurors to seek a fair panel for the case.
Presenting the Evidence
Opening statements, witness testimony, photographs, records and expert testimony are presented in an organized way.
Verdict
After closing arguments, the jury considers the evidence and the judge's instructions and reaches a decision.