A sedan with a crumpled front bumper sits on a suburban road shoulder in late afternoon light, with a tow truck nearby.

Car Accidents | New Orleans, Louisiana

When a Car Accident Claim Has to Be Decided in Court

Przemek Lubecki, the responsible lawyer for this page, explains why some injury claims move toward a courtroom and what that process can involve for the people affected.

By Przemek Lubecki · Published November 11, 2026

Facing a crash claim can leave you asking why a car accident case would go to trial at all. A car accident case usually goes to trial when the sides still disagree about fault, injuries or the value of the claim after talks have ended.

Many claims are resolved long before that point. This page explains what a trial is, why some cases move toward one, and the Louisiana rules that shape that path. Each section gives plain facts from the law, not predictions about any particular claim.

What It Means When a Car Accident Case Goes to Trial

A car accident case goes to trial when a judge or jury hears the evidence and decides the issues the sides could not resolve.

Many claims start with an insurance adjuster. An adjuster investigates the crash and evaluates the claim for the insurance company. If the talks do not produce an agreement, the injured person may file a lawsuit in court.

Once a suit is filed, the case follows court rules and deadlines. At trial, witnesses testify, exhibits are shown, and a jury or judge decides what happened and what the losses are.

Trial is one possible path, not the expected one. Many car accident claims are resolved through talks and never reach a courtroom. The rest of this page explains why cases settle, why some do not, and what happens when they go forward.

If you are weighing whether a crash claim should settle or go to court, you do not have to decide that alone, and we invite you to talk with us about it. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Why Most Car Accident Cases Settle Before Trial

Many car accident cases settle before trial because a settlement ends the dispute sooner. A courtroom process can take considerable time, and both sides carry the cost of continuing.

A settlement also gives both sides certainty. Instead of leaving the result to a jury, the parties agree on how the claim ends. For the injured person, that means a known outcome. For the insurer, it means a known cost instead of an open risk.

Both sides weigh the cost, time and risk of continuing. That weighing is what usually drives the choice.

Settling early does not mean a claim was weak. It often reflects a choice both sides make once the key facts are clear. Each case turns on its own facts, so the right path for one person may differ from another. A court process also adds steps, dates and waiting that can be hard on a family.

Common Reasons a Car Accident Case Ends Up in Court

A case usually heads toward court when the sides still disagree on something important after talks. Several issues tend to cause that.

Fault is often the first. Drivers may give conflicting accounts of who had the right of way or who changed lanes. When witnesses and records do not settle the question, a judge or jury may need to decide it.

The offer can be another sticking point. If the injured person believes an offer does not reflect the documented injuries and losses, and the gap cannot be closed, the claim may go forward.

Medical damages are often contested. The parties may disagree about whether an injury came from the crash, what treatment was needed, or what future care is necessary.

More than one party can be involved. La. Civ. Code art. 2323 requires the fault of all persons who caused or contributed to an injury to be determined, whether or not they are parties to the lawsuit. Other drivers, vehicle owners, employers or property owners may each play a role, and each one adds another point of dispute.

Finally, evidence may conflict. When records point in different directions, the facts must be sorted out, often in court.

How Fault and Evidence Shape the Path to Trial

Fault is usually the first question, and Louisiana’s comparative fault rule decides how it affects recovery (La. Civ. Code art. 2323). The rule depends on when the crash happened.

For accidents and injuries on or after January 1, 2026, a person found 51% or more at fault is not entitled to recover damages. Under La. Civ. Code art. 2323, if a person’s own negligence is equal to or greater than fifty-one percent, that person is not entitled to recover damages. The version of La. Civ. Code art. 2323 in force now was amended by Acts 2025, No. 15, effective January 1, 2026.

Evidence matters for both fault and damages. A crash report is a common starting point. Under La. R.S. 32:398, crash reports are confidential. They are available to the parties, their insurers and their attorneys, among others. On request, they are made available within seven working days after the investigation is completed.

Other evidence includes photographs, vehicle damage, witness statements, traffic camera or dashcam footage, and phone or data records where available.

In a commercial truck crash, federal rules matter too. 49 CFR 395.3 sets maximum driving time and duty limits for property-carrying commercial drivers. Fatigue questions in these crashes are often checked against those limits.

When evidence favors one side but the other side still disputes it, a court may be where the question gets decided.

How Injuries and Damages Can Lead a Case to Trial

Injury documentation is often where a claim gets contested. Medical records and treatment history show what the injuries were and how care progressed.

Medical bills have their own rule. When a health insurer or Medicare paid a contracted medical provider, La. R.S. 9:2800.27 limits recovery of those expenses to the amount actually paid, plus any cost sharing. It does not allow recovery of the amount billed.

Medicare adds another layer.

Future care has limits too. Under La. Civ. Code art. 2315, damages do not include costs for future medical treatment, services, surveillance, or procedures of any kind unless such treatment, services, surveillance, or procedures are directly related to a manifest physical or mental injury or disease.

Lost wages, medical bills and future care needs are documented with records, and the sides sometimes dispute them.

General damages such as pain and suffering work differently. La. Civ. Code art. 2324.1 says much discretion must be left to the judge or jury in assessing damages in these cases. A jury may be asked to weigh these losses.

What Happens Once a Car Accident Case Heads to Court

Once a case is filed, it moves through a set of steps. Each step narrows or sharpens the issues.

Pleadings come first. The complaint lays out the claims, and the answer responds to them. Together they frame what the sides disagree about.

Discovery follows. The parties exchange documents, records and sworn testimony, and many facts are tested at this stage.

Dispositive motions ask the court to decide certain issues before trial. A ruling on one of these can narrow what a jury hears.

At trial, the court selects jurors, and each side gives an opening statement. Witnesses then testify, and the evidence is presented.

Not every case qualifies for a jury.

Insurance is generally kept from the jury too. Under La. Code Evid. art. 411, the amount of coverage is not communicated to the jury unless it is a disputed issue the jury decides. The existence of coverage is not communicated unless a listed exception applies.

Not sure what your next step is?

Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Deciding Whether to Settle or Go to Trial

Whether to accept a settlement or go to trial is the injured person’s decision, made with advice from their lawyer.

People often weigh a few questions. How is recovery progressing? How strong is the evidence? What does the offer cover? How much time and stress would a court process add?

The right choice depends on the facts of each case, the injuries involved and the evidence available.

Before accepting any offer, make sure you understand what the settlement resolves. A settlement ends the claim, so its terms matter.

Common questions

Do most car accident cases go to court?

Many car accident claims are resolved before trial. Trial is one possible path, not the expected one.

What is the deadline to file a car accident lawsuit in Louisiana?

Louisiana generally requires delictual (negligence-based) actions to be filed within two years of injury, but other rules can change that deadline in particular situations, so the time limit for a specific matter should be reviewed promptly. It runs from the day the injury is sustained, under La. Civ. Code art. 3493.1.

Can a car accident case settle after a lawsuit is filed?

Yes. A case can settle at any stage, including after a lawsuit has been filed.

Does a car accident case always go to trial?

No. Trial becomes necessary when a dispute remains that the parties cannot resolve.

Talk With Przemek Lubecki About Your Car Accident Claim

Deciding whether a crash claim should settle or go to court is a hard decision. Many people face it while still recovering and dealing with an insurer.

Przemek Lubecki is the responsible lawyer for the content of this page. He is a trial lawyer with our New Orleans office, which represents people hurt in car, truck and commercial vehicle crashes across Louisiana.

The firm may associate or refer a case to other law firms where that applies.

If you are weighing whether your claim should settle or head to court, you do not have to work through that alone. Request a free case evaluation or call 855-LUBECKI for a free, confidential first consultation, with no obligation to continue.

Attorney advertising. The information on this page is general information, not legal advice; reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with American Trial Lawyer, LLC. Attorney responsible for this content – Przemek Lubecki, licensed in Louisiana and Illinois; office at 414 12th Street, New Orleans, LA 70124. You may be responsible for case costs and expenses in addition to the attorney fee. We may associate with, or refer your case to, other law firms; you will be told in writing before that happens.

What Can Shape the Decision to Go to Trial

Disputed facts

When the parties see the crash differently, the evidence has to be examined closely before anyone can judge how the case should be resolved.

Offers that fall short

A settlement offer may not account for medical care, lost income or the long-term effects of an injury. Reviewing the full picture comes first.

Injuries still developing

Some injuries take months to understand. Decisions made too early can leave important losses out of the picture.

Families and everyday drivers

Car accident claims affect real households. Our team keeps each client informed about where the case stands and what the options are.

Filing suit does not always mean a trial

Many car accident claims are resolved without a trial. Trial is one possible path, and it is not the expected outcome. Every case depends on its own facts, so please speak with a lawyer about your situation before making decisions.

How a Case Moves Toward Trial

Investigation

We gather crash reports, medical records, photographs and witness information to understand what happened and who was affected.

Negotiation

Settlement discussions with insurers continue while the case is being built. We keep you informed about each offer and what it means.

Filing a lawsuit

If a fair resolution cannot be reached through negotiation, we discuss with you whether filing a lawsuit is the right step.

Trial preparation

If the case goes to trial, preparation includes evidence, witness planning and a clear presentation for the judge or jury.

Working with other firms

American Trial Lawyer may associate or refer a case to other law firms when that is in the client's best interest. Office in New Orleans.

Talk with Przemek Lubecki about your car accident in New Orleans. Your first consultation is free, confidential and without obligation.

Related practice areas

Call Now — Free Consultation (855) 582-3254