
Wrongful Death · New Orleans, Louisiana
When a Pre-Existing Condition Is Part of a Wrongful Death Case
Przemek Lubecki and the team at American Trial Lawyer, LLC help New Orleans families understand how an earlier medical condition can affect a wrongful death claim after a truck, car or other crash.
By Przemek Lubecki · Published November 3, 2026
The real questions are whether the crash or incident caused or contributed to the death, and how much of the harm can be tied to the earlier condition. Those answers come from the medical history and cause-of-death findings, so every family’s situation is different.
The short answer for families asking this now
A prior health problem is one of the factors that may be reviewed in a Louisiana wrongful death claim. Diabetes, heart disease, or a seizure disorder before a crash can matter, but it is not the final word.
Most of the work comes down to two questions. First, what caused the death? Second, how much of the harm does the prior condition explain? Insurers often raise the second question early, before anyone has read the medical records closely.
Your family’s answer depends on the medical history, the timeline of the incident, and what the medical examiner or treating doctors concluded. It helps to separate these issues instead of treating a health history as a single problem.
If you are trying to make sense of a death after a crash and a medical history now sits at the center of every conversation, we are glad to talk it through with you, at no cost and with no obligation. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Who may bring a Louisiana wrongful death claim
Under Louisiana Civil Code art. 2315.2, certain surviving family members may sue when a person dies due to another’s fault. The article lists them in order. A surviving spouse and children come first.
If there is no spouse or child, the surviving father and mother, or either of them, may sue, but a father or mother who abandoned the deceased during his minority is deemed not to have survived him. If none of those survive, siblings may sue. If none of them survive, grandparents may sue. Adoptive relatives count under the same article.
The claim recovers damages the survivors sustained because of the death. The decedent’s own injuries and losses before death fall under a separate survival action. Louisiana Civil Code art. 2315.1 says the right to recover those damages survives in favor of the same family members for one year from the death or two years from the day the injury was sustained, whichever is longer. If no listed family member exists, the succession representative may bring it.
Taking the victim as they are
In general, a person who causes harm must repair it, even when the injured person was more vulnerable than most people. Louisiana Civil Code art. 2315 states that every act of man that causes damage to another obliges the person at fault to repair it. This idea is often called the eggshell principle.
The useful question is not whether your loved one was healthy before the crash. It is whether the crash caused the harm, or made an existing condition worse.
Two situations often get mixed up. In one, the incident worsened a condition that was already there. In the other, the condition would have led to the same outcome anyway. Medical opinions usually decide which situation fits the facts.
Where a pre-existing condition becomes a causation and apportionment issue
The other side often argues about how much of the harm, or of the death, came from the prior condition. That is a question of dividing responsibility for the harm. It is not, by itself, an automatic end to the claim.
Comparative fault is a separate question. Under Louisiana Civil Code art. 2323, fault is assigned to everyone who caused or contributed to the injury or death, including people who are not parties to the case. La. Civ. Code art. 2323 provides that when a person suffers injury, death, or loss partly as the result of his own negligence and partly as a result of the fault of another person or persons, and the negligence attributable to him is equal to or greater than fifty-one percent, he shall not be entitled to recover damages, except that if the other person’s fault is that of an intentional tortfeasor, his claim for recovery of damages shall not be reduced. When the negligence attributable to a person suffering injury, death, or loss is less than fifty-one percent, La. Civ. Code art. 2323 states that the amount of damages recoverable shall be reduced in proportion to the degree or percentage of negligence attributable to that person.
A health history is not the same thing as conduct behind the wheel. Keep those ideas apart when you talk with anyone about the case.
When more than one party is at fault, Louisiana Civil Code art. 2324 says that liability that is not solidary is joint and divisible. A party is not liable for more than its own degree of fault.
Questions that usually come up include:
- How was the condition being managed before the crash?
- Did the crash change its course?
- What did the medical examiner and treating doctors conclude about cause and timing?
Records and evidence that usually shape the question
The records that most often shape this issue are the decedent’s medical history, the death certificate, and any autopsy or cause-of-death report. Records from before and after the incident matter too. So do prescription history, emergency room notes, and imaging taken close to the crash.
Crash reports are confidential under La. R.S. 32:398. Upon request, they are to be made available within seven working days after the crash investigation is completed, but only to those the law lists, such as the parties to the crash, their insurers, and their attorneys or succession representatives.
Families can help in a few simple ways. Keep all medical papers in one place. Write a timeline of symptoms, medications, and the days before and after the incident while memories are fresh. Do not throw away or change the decedent’s records, medication bottles, or phone without first talking through what to keep.
How a prior condition can affect each category of damages
Economic losses are usually tied to the decedent’s health, work history, and expected working years. Lost income, lost support, and lost household services are common examples. Prior health can matter here, because a defense may argue the decedent would have earned less or worked fewer years anyway.
Non-economic losses are different. They include loss of love, affection, companionship, and guidance. Louisiana Civil Code art. 2315 says damages may include loss of consortium, service, and society, recoverable by the same people who could bring a wrongful death claim. La. Civ. Code art. 2315 reads: “Damages do not include costs for future medical treatment, services, surveillance, or procedures of any kind unless such treatment, services, surveillance, or procedures are directly related to a manifest physical or mental injury or disease.” These losses are not measured by a formula.
Future medical costs have a limit. Under the same article, damages do not include future medical treatment unless it is directly related to a manifest physical or mental injury or disease. A prior condition can make that link a central question.
In a survival claim, the decedent’s own pain and suffering before death may be part of the case. The separation between crash injuries and the prior condition is often where the medical evidence matters most.
Not sure what your next step is?
Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.
Filing deadlines depend on when the death or injury occurred
The wrongful death right of action prescribes one year from the death of the deceased or two years from the day that injury or damage is sustained, whichever is longer, under Louisiana Civil Code art. 2315.2, except that for medical malpractice actions it prescribes one year from the death of the deceased. Families should learn this rule early.
Medical questions, records requests, and disputes over cause can take months. Families should not assume those questions pause the deadline. How the period applies to a particular death depends on the facts, including the dates of the injury and the death.
Our team can review those dates with you early, so timing is not a surprise later.

Talking through your family’s situation with Przemek Lubecki
If you are reading this after losing someone you love, you may be grieving and handling health questions at the same time. Those are heavy things to carry at once.
A free, confidential first consultation, with no obligation to continue, can help you see how these questions apply to your family’s facts. Przemek Lubecki is the responsible lawyer for this page, and the firm’s office is in New Orleans. Przemek Lubecki is licensed to practice law in Louisiana.
The firm may associate or refer a case to other law firms where appropriate. Every case turns on its own facts, and no outcome can be promised.
Common questions
How a pre-existing condition may factor into a wrongful death claim in Louisiana
Each case turns on its own facts, including any pre-existing condition. Causation, fault, and damages questions decide how much the condition matters.
Families should not assume medical questions pause that period.
Who may bring the claim?
Certain surviving spouses, children, parents, siblings, or grandparents may sue, in the order that article lists.
If you want to talk through what happened, call 855-LUBECKI or request a free case evaluation with our New Orleans office.
What families often ask us
Cause of death
A key question is whether the crash caused or contributed to the death, and what role the earlier condition played.
Medical records
Prior medical records and cause-of-death findings often shape how a claim is evaluated, so they are reviewed closely.
Making the full picture clear
Explaining how an existing condition relates to the injury can be as important as the crash facts themselves.
Plain-language guidance
We explain each step in clear terms so families know what to expect as they make decisions.
Questions to bring to your consultation
What was the medical history?
Bring any records about diagnoses, treatment and medications in the months and years before the incident.
What did the cause-of-death report say?
Copies of the death certificate, autopsy findings and hospital records help us understand what the medical team concluded.
Who was involved?
Note the other driver, company, vehicle type and any witnesses, along with any police or crash reports you have.
Who in the family is affected?
Consider who depended on your loved one and what losses the family has experienced since the death.
Important: every case is different
This page is general information, not legal advice about your situation. The firm may associate or refer a case to other law firms. Przemek Lubecki is the responsible lawyer for this page. Our New Orleans office offers a free, confidential first consultation with no obligation to continue.