
Car and Truck Accident Guide | New Orleans, Louisiana
Shared Blame After a Crash: What Louisiana Comparative Fault Means for Injured People
A plain-language look at how shared fault can affect an injury claim, and the questions to bring to a lawyer.
By Przemek Lubecki · Published November 16, 2026
Louisiana comparative fault personal injury cases raise one hard question: were you partly to blame for the crash? A partial share of blame does not always end a claim. The result depends on when the crash happened and on the percentage of fault each person carries. This page explains how the rule works, how fault gets divided in truck and car crashes, and what evidence tends to matter. It is general information, not advice about your own case.
Does Louisiana’s Comparative Fault Rule Reduce or Bar Recovery if the Injured Person Was Partly Responsible for the Crash?
How fault is divided between the people involved can affect the amount of a recovery, which is why the facts of each crash matter. Under Louisiana Civil Code article 2323(A)(2)(a), if the percentage of negligence attributable to the person who suffered the injury, death, or loss is equal to or greater than fifty-one percent, that person is not entitled to recover damages. However, if the injury was caused partly by an intentional tortfeasor, the article says the person’s claim is not reduced.
The rule sits in La. Civil Code art. 2323. The article requires the fault of everyone who caused or contributed to an injury to be determined. That includes people who are not parties to the lawsuit. The article applies to any claim for injury, death, or loss, whatever the legal theory.
Partial responsibility is a matter of degree, not an all-or-nothing label. A person found less than 51 percent at fault can still recover, with damages reduced in proportion to their share, except where the person’s injury results partly from their own negligence and partly from the fault of an intentional tortfeasor, in which case the claim is not reduced (La. Civ. Code art. 2323). The rule alone can’t tell you how a particular claim will turn out.
If you're worried you may be blamed for a crash, or you're helping a family member through one, you don't have to sort out fault alone. Call 855-LUBECKI to talk with our New Orleans office. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.
How Is Fault Percentage Assigned in a Truck or Car Crash in Louisiana?
A judge or jury assigns a percentage of fault to each person whose conduct contributed to the crash. A single crash can involve several at-fault parties. The driver is one. The vehicle owner or an employer may be others.
Under La. Civil Code art. 2320, an employer answers for damage caused by employees while they do the work they were employed to do. That responsibility attaches only when the employer might have prevented the act and did not.
When two or more persons are liable, La. Civil Code art. 2324 makes their liability a joint and divisible obligation, except that a person who conspires with another to commit an intentional or willful act is answerable in solido with that person for the resulting damage. In plain terms, each party is responsible for its own degree of fault, not the whole amount. The proof in each case decides how the shares fall.
How Does a Partial Fault Finding Affect the Amount of a Recovery?
Here is a simple example. It is illustrative only and is not a prediction.
Suppose a judge or jury set total damages at 100 units and found the injured driver 20 percent at fault. Under the reduction rule, the recovery would fall to 80 units. The units stand in for whatever dollar amount the proven damages equal.
Two points matter here. Proof of injury and loss is an important part of any claim, alongside the facts about how the crash happened. Second, Louisiana law says much discretion in assessing damages must be left to the judge or jury. This example refers to no past case and promises no result.
What Arguments Do Insurers and Defendants Commonly Raise About the Injured Person’s Conduct?
Insurers and defendants often look at the injured person’s speed, lane position, attention, and driving habits. The aim is to shift a share of fault onto the injured person. These arguments are common, but they are tested against the physical evidence and testimony. They are not accepted just because someone raises them.
Careful driving is the standard. Under La. R.S. 32:58, a driver must operate a vehicle in a careful and prudent manner. Failing to do so is careless operation. Lane rules matter too. Under La. R.S. 32:79, on a roadway divided into two or more clearly marked lanes, a vehicle shall be driven as nearly as practicable entirely within a single lane and shall not be moved from that lane until the driver has first ascertained that the movement can be made with safety.
Statements often shape a claim early. If you gave a written or recorded statement, La. R.S. 13:3732 says the person who took it must give you a true and complete copy within twenty days after written demand. Be careful how you describe who was at fault, and keep copies of anything you sign.

How Does Comparative Fault Apply When a Commercial Truck Is Involved?
Truck crashes often involve more than one party. The driver, the motor carrier that operates the truck, and sometimes a broker who arranged the load can each have a role. Each party’s conduct is weighed, and the injured person’s conduct is compared against all of them.
Records can help show what each party knew and did. Driver logs, maintenance history, and hiring files are examples. What they show can shape the fault split in a case.
Federal law can also affect these claims.
What Evidence Typically Shapes the Fault Percentages in a Louisiana Crash Claim?
The police crash report, photographs, vehicle damage, witness statements, medical records, and vehicle data often shape fault percentages. No single item decides the split. Each one is weighed alongside the rest.
Crash reports have specific access rules. Under La. R.S. 32:398, crash reports are confidential. On request, they must be made available within seven working days after the crash investigation is completed.
Timing matters. Photos, skid marks, and vehicle data can change or disappear. Witnesses move, and memories fade. Gathering evidence early makes it easier to show how the crash happened. Keep medical notes, receipts, and a written timeline of what you remember.
Not sure what your next step is?
Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.
How Does Comparative Fault Work in a Louisiana Wrongful Death Case?
In a wrongful death case, the deceased person’s own fault is weighed under the same comparative fault article. La. Civil Code art. 2323 applies to any claim for death. A family’s claim can be reduced by the share of fault found on the person who died.
Who may sue is set by La. Civil Code art. 2315.2. The surviving spouse and children come first. If there is no spouse or child, the surviving father and mother may sue, or either of them if the deceased left no spouse or child surviving. Brothers and sisters and then grandparents follow, in that order, if no one closer survived, and a father or mother who has abandoned the deceased during his minority is deemed not to have survived him.
Timing is strict. Under the same article, the wrongful death claim prescribes, meaning the deadline runs out, one year from the death or two years from the day the injury was sustained, whichever is longer. A survival action for the deceased’s own damages follows a similar period under La. Civil Code art. 2315.1.
Families often ask whether a loved one’s partial blame changes their claim. The answer rests on the specific facts of the crash, so it is worth raising early.
Talk With the New Orleans Office About Your Crash and Your Fault Questions
You may be researching while still dealing with injuries, a loss, or a claim you did not choose. Worry about being blamed is common, and it can weigh heavily while you sort out what happened. If that sounds like your situation, you don’t have to work out the fault questions alone.
Przemek Lubecki is the responsible lawyer for this page. The firm’s office is in New Orleans. You can request a free case evaluation or call 855-LUBECKI. The first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue, but you may be responsible for case costs and expenses in addition to the fee. The firm may associate or refer a case to other law firms. For more on truck crash claims, read the truck accidents New Orleans guide.
Frequently asked questions
How does fault affect a claim?
Fault is one of several questions that can shape a claim, so the details of each crash matter. An injured person whose own share of negligence is fifty-one percent or greater cannot recover damages under Louisiana Civil Code article 2323. The exception is when the injury was caused partly by an intentional tortfeasor; then the claim is not reduced.
What is the 51% rule?
Under the amended article 2323, a person found 51 percent or more at fault recovers no damages. Someone below that line has damages reduced by their share.
Can a family recover if their loved one was partly at fault?
The same reduction rule applies to a wrongful death claim. The outcome rests on the specific facts of the crash.
What we focus on when reviewing a crash
A careful review of the facts
Every crash is different. We look closely at how the collision happened and what each driver did before it.
Evidence that supports the account
Photos, records, witness statements and vehicle data can help show what happened on the road.
Injured people and grieving families
Whether you were hurt or lost a loved one, we explain your options in clear, everyday language.
A free first consultation
The first consultation is free, confidential and without obligation to continue.
Talk with a lawyer about your specific crash
Shared fault questions depend on the details of your case. Przemek Lubecki and our team at American Trial Lawyer, LLC, with our office in New Orleans, can review your situation in a free, confidential consultation. The firm may associate or refer a case to other law firms.
Details to gather before you call
When and where it happened
Note the date, time, location and road conditions, including weather and lighting.
Who was involved
Write down the names and contact details of drivers, passengers, employers and any commercial carrier.
Your injuries and treatment
Keep records of doctor visits, diagnoses, medications and days missed from work.
Witnesses and photos
Save photos of the scene and vehicles, and any contact information for people who saw the crash.