A technician uses a laptop to access a delivery van's data recorder at its open rear doors in an early-morning impound lot.

Wrongful Death | Office in New Orleans, Louisiana

When Family Members Disagree About a Wrongful Death Lawsuit

Przemek Lubecki and our team at American Trial Lawyer, LLC help families in Orleans Parish and across Louisiana work through disagreements about a wrongful death claim, with clear information and a calm, organized approach.

By Przemek Lubecki · Published October 28, 2026

When Family Members Disagree About a Wrongful Death Lawsuit in Louisiana

If your relatives are divided after a loss in a crash, you don't have to sort out who files and how recovery is shared alone. Call 855-LUBECKI or request a free case evaluation. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

A man loads furniture into an open van in a daytime parking lot.

When Relatives Disagree About a Wrongful Death Claim

Louisiana law decides who may bring a wrongful death claim. When relatives disagree, those rules give the family a clear starting point.

Losing someone in a crash is painful. Grief, money worries, and different relationships with the person who died can all shape how relatives see the next step. Most disagreements come down to three decisions:

  • Whether to file a lawsuit now or wait.
  • Who acts as the plaintiff, meaning the person who brings the claim.
  • How any recovery is shared.

American Trial Lawyer is led by trial lawyer Przemek Lubecki. Our New Orleans office handles wrongful death cases for families in Orleans Parish, the New Orleans metro area and across Louisiana. This page gives general information, not legal advice about your case. For the broader filing process, read how to file a wrongful death lawsuit in Orleans Parish.

Who Louisiana Law Allows to Bring a Wrongful Death Claim

The surviving spouse and children may sue first under Louisiana Civil Code art. 2315.2. If there is no spouse or child, the surviving parents may sue. If there is no spouse, child or parent, the surviving brothers and sisters may sue. If none of those relatives survive, grandparents may sue.

The statute often says “either” or “any of them.” That means one eligible person in a group may bring the suit. Adopted relatives count in the same groups.

The law looks at family relationship.

Eligibility can also be cut off. A parent who abandoned the child during minority is treated as not having survived. The law presumes abandonment when a parent left the child for at least twelve months and did not provide care or support, without just cause. Families should raise this early if it applies.

Under Louisiana Civil Code art. 2315.5, a surviving spouse, parent, or child who was convicted of a crime involving the intentional killing or attempted killing of the deceased is not entitled to any damages or proceeds in a survival action or an action for wrongful death. Under Louisiana Civil Code art. 2315.5, the same bar applies if a court judicially determined that the surviving spouse, parent, or child participated in the intentional, unjustified killing or attempted killing of the deceased. Under Louisiana Civil Code art. 2315.5, an executive pardon does not restore that right.

A lawyer can review the family tree and confirm who falls within each group.

Wrongful Death Damages Versus Survival Claims

A wrongful death claim covers the losses the family itself suffered. A survival claim covers the injury claim the person who died could have brought.

Under the wrongful death statute, eligible people may “recover damages which they sustained as a result of the death.” That is the family’s own loss.

The survival claim is different. Under Louisiana Civil Code art. 2315.1, the deceased person’s right to recover damages survives for the same family groups. The period is one year from the death or two years from the injury, whichever is longer, except that the prescriptive period for medical malpractice survival actions is governed by R.S. 9:5628.

A succession representative may urge the survival claim only when no listed family group survives. This is one place where families can split. Under La. Civ. Code art. 2315.1, in the absence of any class of beneficiary set out in Paragraph A, the right to recover all damages for injury to the deceased may be urged by the deceased’s succession representative.

A family may agree on one claim and disagree about the other. A lawyer can explain which claim fits the facts. Readers whose crash involved a teen driver can read whether a family can sue after a teen driver crash.

Disagreement Over Whether to File a Lawsuit

Relatives often split between acting now and waiting. The deadline does not pause while the family talks.

Under art. 2315.2, the right of action prescribes, or runs out, one year from the death or two years from the injury, whichever is longer. Inheriting the claim does not extend that period.

Filing and then dropping a case can also hurt. Under Louisiana Civil Code art. 3463, if a plaintiff abandons the suit, voluntarily dismisses it, or fails to prosecute it at trial, the filing is treated as if the time limit was never interrupted, but a dismissal pursuant to a compromise does not count as a voluntary dismissal. Filing a suit in the right court and venue matters too. Louisiana Civil Code art. 3462 explains how filing interrupts the time limit.

Families also ask how the cause on a death certificate fits with the crash. The page on death certificate cause questions covers that topic. Some cases may belong in federal court, which is discussed on the federal court wrongful death page.

A lawyer can lay out the timeline and each option in writing. That way, relatives decide from the same facts.

Disagreement Over Who Serves as Plaintiff or Representative

Under the statute, one eligible relative may file in many cases. Because several groups say “either” or “any of them,” more than one relative may qualify. The family may need to decide who files.

A succession representative may bring the survival claim only in the narrow case described in art. 2315.1(B).

The roles carry different duties. A lawyer can explain each role before the family chooses. Clear information helps relatives make that choice without pressure from either side.

Not sure what your next step is?

Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Disagreement Over Dividing a Settlement or Verdict

Each eligible person’s share is tied to the losses that person sustained. In a survival claim, the deceased person’s own right to recover all damages for injury to that person, his property or otherwise, caused by the offense or quasi offense, survives for one year from the death or two years from the day the injury or damage is sustained, whichever is longer (medical malpractice survival actions follow R.S. 9:5628 instead).

Louisiana law gives judges and juries much discretion in assessing damages. Under Louisiana Civil Code art. 2324.1, that discretion applies in cases of offenses and quasi offenses. The amount for one family depends on the facts of that family’s loss. No formula can settle it in advance.

Any agreement on dividing a recovery works best in writing. A lawyer should review the terms before anyone signs. Putting terms on paper early can reduce confusion later, when relatives may be under strain.

Practical Steps That Keep a Family’s Claim on Track

Keep the crash report, medical bills, the death certificate, photos and any messages about the crash in one secure place. Crash reports are confidential under La. R.S. 32:398. They are available only to the parties to the crash, parents or guardians of a minor who is a party to the crash, their insurers or insurance support organizations under contract to provide claims and underwriting, any healthcare provider or their agent that rendered services to a party, succession representatives, attorneys, and news-gathering organizations requesting documents related to a specific crash. Upon request, they are made available within seven working days after the crash investigation is complete.

Wrongful death filings also need paperwork.

Family members should not sign papers from insurance companies without first speaking with a lawyer. Naming one point of contact for the lawyer can also reduce confusion when relatives disagree.

American Trial Lawyer may associate or refer a case to other law firms. Any such step would be explained to the family before it happens.

Technician downloads data from a delivery van's recorder using a laptop at an impound lot at dawn.

Talk With a Lawyer About Your Family’s Situation

Families who disagree about a wrongful death lawsuit can get clear answers before they decide anything. Bring these questions to the first meeting:

  • Who is eligible under the statute?
  • Which deadlines apply to this loss?
  • Who should file, and in what role?
  • How would any recovery be divided, and how should that be written down?

The first consultation is free, confidential and without obligation. There is no commitment to continue.

Frequently Asked Questions

Because time limits are strict, families should not wait.

Can one relative file for the family?

Yes, in many cases. The statute’s “either” and “any of them” wording lets one eligible relative bring the suit.

Is the first consultation free?

Yes. The first consultation is free, confidential and without obligation.

If your family is divided after a loss in a crash, call 855-LUBECKI or request a free case evaluation. Przemek Lubecki is the responsible lawyer for this page, and our New Orleans office can talk through your family’s options with you.

Attorney advertising. The information on this page is general information, not legal advice; reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with American Trial Lawyer, LLC. Attorney responsible for this content – Przemek Lubecki, licensed in Louisiana and Illinois; office at 414 12th Street, New Orleans, LA 70124. You may be responsible for case costs and expenses in addition to the attorney fee. We may associate with, or refer your case to, other law firms; you will be told in writing before that happens.

How we approach a family disagreement

Plain-language answers

We explain the process in everyday terms so every family member understands what is happening and why.

Every voice is heard

Disagreements are often rooted in grief. We listen to each relative's concerns before any decisions are discussed.

Organized information

We help gather and keep track of the records, dates and details that matter to the family's questions.

Confidential first consultation

The first consultation is free, confidential and without obligation to continue.

Common sources of disagreement

Who speaks for the family

Relatives may disagree about who should lead the case or make decisions on the family's behalf.

Different views on the case

Family members can see the same loss in different ways, which can make it hard to agree on next steps.

Questions about settlement talks

Some relatives want to move quickly while others want more time to understand what is being discussed.

Breakdowns in communication

When relatives stop speaking to one another, important information can be lost. A calm, organized process can help.

Please note: case referral

American Trial Lawyer, LLC may associate or refer a wrongful death case to other law firms. If a referral or association is planned, we will let you know before anything changes.

Talk with Przemek Lubecki about your family's situation

Call Now — Free Consultation (855) 582-3254