
Car Accidents | New Orleans, Louisiana
Hurt Before the Crash? You May Still Have Questions Worth Asking
A past back, neck or head injury does not end the conversation. Here is how an old injury and a new crash can be looked at side by side.
By Przemek Lubecki · Published November 21, 2026
If a crash made an old back, neck, or knee problem worse, you may be wondering whether the new harm counts. A person hurt by another’s fault can seek repair for the harm that fault caused, and that can include a worsening of a condition that already existed.
This page explains what an aggravated prior injury means, which records matter, how Louisiana fault and deadline rules work, and what to do next. It is general information, not a prediction about any particular claim.
What Does It Mean When an Old Injury Is Made Worse in a Car Accident?
An aggravated pre-existing injury is a condition you had before a crash that the crash made worse, more painful, or more limiting.
Think of it as two pictures. The first shows how the condition affected you before the crash. That might mean how often your back flared, what you could lift, or how far you could walk. The second shows how it affects you now.
The gap between those two pictures is the harm a car accident claim looks at. The old condition itself is not the new harm.
Take a common example. A person with a long history of low back pain is hit from behind. Before the crash, the pain came and went with treatment. After it, the pain is constant and the person has limits that did not exist before. A claim would focus on that change.
A knee that was stable before a collision and now gives way is another example. Every case is different. This is general information, not a promise about how any claim will turn out.
If a crash in Orleans Parish made an old back, neck, or knee problem worse, we can review your records and the crash facts with you. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Can a Louisiana Car Accident Claim Cover a Pre-Existing Condition That Got Worse?
How a prior condition affects a claim depends on the facts of each case, so the details of your medical history matter.
The basic rule is in La. Civ. Code art. 2315. It says every act of a person that causes damage to another obliges the person whose fault caused it to repair that damage. La. Civ. Code art. 2316 adds that a person is responsible for damage caused by negligence, imprudence, or want of skill.
In practice, the other driver is generally responsible for the change the crash caused when that driver’s negligence, imprudence, or want of skill caused it, since a person is responsible for damage occasioned not merely by his act, but by his negligence, his imprudence, or his want of skill. Prior medical conditions often come up in these cases, so it helps to talk through your history with a lawyer. Because the claim centers on the change, the before-and-after picture matters from the start.
Medical records should make that link clear.
Why Prior Medical Records Matter Before and After the Crash
Records from before and after the crash are the main way to show what changed. Each set answers a different question.
Earlier records set the baseline. These can include primary care notes, prior X-rays or MRIs, physical therapy or chiropractic notes, pain management records, and prescription history. They show how the condition was treated and how it was doing before the crash.
Records from after the crash show what changed. These usually include emergency visits, new imaging, specialist referrals, work restrictions, and changes in treatment. A doctor who reviews the old and new records together can describe the difference.
Louisiana law adds one point to keep in mind. La. Code Evid. art. 306.1 provides that, in a personal injury claim outside workers’ compensation, the lack of a prior history does not create a presumption that the condition was caused by the act in question. Having no prior history does not give a claim an automatic advantage. The proof comes from the records and the medical picture.
Request copies of your records from each provider and keep them in one place. Write down when symptoms began or changed, and what you were doing at the time. Describe what you notice, and leave the question of cause to your doctor.
Why Symptoms Sometimes Appear Days or Weeks After a Crash
A new or worse symptom can show up hours, days, or weeks after a crash. Back, neck, and knee symptoms are common examples.
Some people feel sore right after a crash. Then they notice stiffness, numbness, or sharper pain a few days later. Others have a flare of an old condition once they return to normal activities.
A later start does not automatically mean the crash did not cause the symptom. It does make prompt medical evaluation and a clear timeline more important.
Get any new or increased symptom checked by a medical provider, even if it seems minor. That care supports your health, and the records it creates also document when symptoms began.
Keep a simple log. Note the date, the symptom, how severe it is, and what makes it better or worse. A log does not replace medical care, but it gives your doctor and any later review a clear account. For more on soft-tissue symptoms after a crash, see neck and whiplash symptoms.
How Louisiana Fault Rules and Adjusters Affect an Aggravation Claim
Louisiana reduces a recovery by the injured person’s share of fault, and it bars recovery when that share reaches 51 percent or more.
La. Civ. Code art. 2323 sets that rule. A person whose share of fault is 51 percent or more recovers no damages. A person whose share is less than 51 percent has recovery reduced in proportion to that share.
The article was amended by 2025 Acts, No. 15, effective January 1, 2026. The date of the crash matters, so confirm it before relying on any version of the rule.
Fault is often disputed. Adjusters commonly look at the police report, photos, statements from drivers and witnesses, and vehicle damage. When a prior condition is involved, they also ask whether the condition existed before and whether the crash changed it.
La. R.S. 32:398 governs crash reports. A driver in a crash involving injury must give his or her name, address, and vehicle registration to anyone injured. Crash reports are confidential. Upon request, they are made available to the parties to the crash, their attorneys and insurers, and certain others within seven working days after the investigation is complete. Request the report early, while the details are fresh.
What Damages May Be Considered for an Aggravated Injury?
Damages for an aggravated injury generally cover the harm the crash caused, not the whole history of the condition.
Economic damages are money losses you can document. These can include medical bills for care tied to the worsening and income lost because of it.
When a health insurer has paid medical bills, Louisiana limits what can be recovered. Under La. R.S. 9:2800.27, recovery is limited to the amount actually paid to a contracted provider, plus applicable cost-sharing amounts, not the amount billed.
Other damages cover things like physical pain, limits on daily life, and loss of enjoyment caused by the worsening. Louisiana law leaves much of this to the judge or jury. La. Civ. Code art. 2324.1 says that in assessing damages in cases of offenses, quasi offenses, and quasi contracts, much discretion must be left to the judge or jury.
The central task is separating old harm from new harm. If a condition already limited you, the claim focuses on the extra limit the crash added. Any value depends on the medical picture, the records, and the facts of the crash.
Not sure what your next step is?
Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.
What If the Other Driver Has No Insurance?
If the at-fault driver has no insurance, your own auto policy may include uninsured motorist coverage that can apply.
Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage can help when the other driver’s insurance is missing or too small. Check your policy’s declarations page and your insurance card, and keep copies with your crash records. The terms of your own policy control what applies.
Louisiana has special rules for crashes without contact. La. R.S. 22:1295 says that when an uninsured or unidentified vehicle never physically touched the covered vehicle, the injured party must prove by an independent and disinterested witness that the injury resulted from that driver’s actions.
Timing matters too. La. R.S. 9:5629 says actions under the uninsured motorist provisions of an auto policy are prescribed by two years from the accident date.
Should I Talk to the Other Driver’s Insurance Company?
You can speak with an insurer, but it helps to understand each request before you answer.
Insurers often ask for a recorded statement, medical records, and a signed authorization. These requests can arrive quickly, sometimes before you have full medical information.
Under La. R.S. 13:3732, an injured person who gives a written, recorded, or transcribed statement about an accident or injury is entitled to a true and complete copy. A copy must be furnished within twenty days after written demand. A statement is not admissible in a related civil action if the holder refused to provide that copy on request.
Answer accurately and stick to what you know. It is fine to say you need time to review your records.
Your own health insurance may help pay bills while a claim is open. If your auto policy has medical payments coverage, that may help too. If you have Medicare, Medicare.gov explains that when an insurer does not pay promptly, usually within 120 days, a provider may bill Medicare. Medicare may make a conditional payment that it can later recover. CMS explains that a conditional payment must be repaid when a settlement, judgment, award, or other payment is made.
How Long Does a Claim Take, and What Deadlines Apply?
Louisiana generally gives two years from the day of injury to file a claim for damages, so the crash date starts the clock (La. Civ. Code art. 3493.1).
La. Civ. Code art. 3493.1 sets a two-year prescription for delictual (tort) actions. It runs from the day injury or damage is sustained. That article was amended by 2024 Acts, No. 423, effective July 1, 2024. It also contains exceptions, including for some minors, so the details matter.
An uninsured motorist claim has its own two-year period under La. R.S. 9:5629, measured from the accident date.
How long a claim takes cannot be promised. The time varies with treatment, the completeness of records, and the insurer’s review. Write the crash date in your records now, because a missed deadline can affect a claim.

Talk With Przemek Lubecki About Your Own Records and Crash
A consultation is the place to review your own records and the facts of your crash.
Can I recover if I had a back injury before the crash?
Questions about a pre-existing condition depend on the specific facts. The initial consultation is free, confidential and without obligation to continue.
Does a prior injury automatically weaken a claim?
No, not automatically. A prior condition changes what the records need to show, so the before-and-after picture carries the weight.
How long do I have to file?
Louisiana generally allows two years from the day of injury for these claims, with exceptions, so confirm the date for your crash (La. Civ. Code art. 3493.1).
Przemek Lubecki is the responsible lawyer for this page’s content. He is licensed to practice law in Louisiana. The office is in New Orleans, Louisiana.
American Trial Lawyer may associate or refer a case to other law firms. Any co-counsel is not part of American Trial Lawyer, LLC.
If a crash in Orleans Parish or the New Orleans area made an old back, neck, or knee problem worse, you can contact our New Orleans office for a free consultation or call 855-LUBECKI. The initial consultation is free, confidential, and without obligation to continue. For more on car accident claims in Orleans Parish, see the Orleans Parish car accident claims guide.
What Often Helps Show the Change
Medical history
Records from before and after the crash, including visits, imaging and treatment notes, help show how the condition looked before and how it changed.
A clear timeline
Notes on when symptoms started, grew worse, or began affecting work, sleep or daily tasks can make the change easier to follow.
Honest daily details
Everyday limits you notice, such as lifting, driving or standing, matter as much as the formal diagnosis.
Careful review
Each file is reviewed on its own facts, with attention to how the old and new injuries relate.
Tip: Share Your Full History
Tell your doctors and your lawyer about prior injuries, even minor ones or ones you think have healed. Leaving out history can make a claim harder to evaluate, while complete records make it easier to explain what changed.
Common Questions
Does an old injury weaken a claim?
Not automatically.
What if my doctor saw this before?
Earlier treatment is often part of the story. Medical notes from before the crash can help show a baseline, and gaps in records are worth discussing early.
Will my case be handled by another firm?
We may associate with or refer a case to other law firms. If that may happen in your matter, we will tell you.