A sedan with a crumpled front bumper parked on a suburban road shoulder in late afternoon light, with a tow truck nearby.

Car Accidents | New Orleans

Have Questions About Medical Records After a Car Accident?

Learn what to look for before you sign a release, and when it makes sense to get guidance from a trial lawyer.

By Przemek Lubecki · Published November 11, 2026

A letter from an insurance adjuster asking for your medical records can arrive soon after a car crash. Many people wonder whether they have to hand over everything. Questions about an insurance adjuster’s requests for information are worth discussing with a lawyer before you respond. What you sign and send decides how much it reaches.

This page explains what insurers ask for, what a medical authorization form does, and what to check before you respond. It covers Louisiana law in general terms. It is not advice about your own claim.

Short Answer: What You Must Hand Over and What You Can Limit

You control what you sign and what you send, and those choices shape your claim. A subpoena in a lawsuit works differently from a letter from an adjuster, so keep the two separate in your mind.

Keep the request letter and every form you received. Write down the date each one arrived. Read the whole form before you sign it, including the small print at the bottom.

Many people make the same mistakes. They sign a form without reading it. They answer questions by phone before they have looked at their own records. They send a long history when the claim only needs the crash-related care. Slowing down prevents most of these problems.

If you are unsure what a request covers, that is a good reason to speak with a lawyer before you sign anything.

If an adjuster has sent you a records request or a form to sign after your crash, we can review it with you before you decide anything. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

A sedan with a crumpled front bumper sits on a suburban road shoulder in late afternoon light, with a tow truck waiting nearby.

Why the Insurance Company Asks for Your Medical Records

Insurers ask for medical records to check the injuries you claim, the care you received, and whether the crash caused them. Records show diagnoses, imaging results, treatment plans, and provider notes. An adjuster reads those notes to see when symptoms started and how they changed.

Expect two kinds of records. Records about injuries from the crash are the core of the claim. Records about unrelated health history are a different matter. A request that reaches far beyond the crash is worth questioning.

Adjusters also often ask for records from providers you saw before the crash. This is a common part of the review. Knowing why it is being asked helps you decide how to answer.

Bills are part of the review too. In some cases, Louisiana limits recovery of past medical expenses to the amount actually paid, not the amount billed. In a trial, the people deciding the case are told both amounts.

If Medicare has paid some of your bills, its secondary payer rules also matter. The Medicare secondary payer overview explains how Medicare works alongside other insurance.

Medical Authorization Forms: What to Check Before You Sign

A medical authorization is a signed permission. It lets a provider release your records to the insurer. Once you sign it, the form can open the door to more than the claim needs.

Check these parts before you sign:

  • The named providers. Does the form list only the doctors and facilities tied to the crash, or a long list of everyone you have seen?
  • The date range. Does it cover the weeks or months around the accident, or many years of care?
  • The record types. Does it name specific records, such as imaging or billing, or cover everything?
  • The wording. Does it say “all records” or “any and all” health information?

A limited form covers the accident providers and the accident dates. A broad release can reach a long health history. You can ask the insurer, in writing, to narrow the request to the providers and dates tied to the crash.

Keep a copy of anything you sign and a copy of your letter. Asking for a narrower form is a normal step, and it creates a written record of what you agreed to.

If you gave a recorded or written statement, Louisiana law lets you ask for a copy. Whoever took the statement or has possession of it or a copy must give you a true and complete copy, and if you make a written demand, must furnish it within twenty days after that demand. La. R.S. 13:3732 sets out that rule.

Can the Insurance Company Use Your Records Against Your Claim?

Yes, an insurer can read your records for earlier injuries, past treatment, or gaps in care. It may use those points when it takes a position on your claim. How the records are read matters, and an insurer’s reading is not the final word.

Records can also help your claim. They document injuries from the crash, such as the first visit after the accident and the symptoms written down there. A complete record can show the timeline of your care.

Louisiana’s evidence rule speaks to one common worry. In a personal injury claim outside workers’ compensation, the lack of a prior history of an illness or injury does not by itself create a presumption that the crash caused it. See La. Code Evid. art. 306.1.

Keep a simple log of your symptoms, appointments, and time missed from work. Answer questions from what you remember and what your records show. Do not guess about past care.

Why Insurers Ask About Old Injuries and Prior Records

Adjusters often ask for older records to compare your health before and after the crash. Having an earlier condition does not end the discussion. The main question is usually which injuries the crash caused, and records help answer it.

Accurate answers matter more than short ones. An insurer can check your answers against the records it receives. An answer that does not match the records invites more questions, and those questions take time.

Before you respond, write a timeline. List past treatment, the providers, the approximate dates, and the symptoms you had. Then compare it with the records you are being asked to release.

If an old injury is part of the picture, say so plainly. A short, honest answer that the records confirm is easier to work with than a vague answer that leaves gaps.

Should You Tell Your Own Insurer About the Accident?

Yes, you should usually report the accident to your own auto insurer promptly. Most auto policies ask the policyholder to give prompt notice of a loss. The wording of your policy sets the details.

Notice and a detailed statement are different steps. Telling your insurer a crash happened is one step. Giving a detailed recorded statement to the other driver’s insurer is another, and it deserves more thought before you give it.

Settling a property damage claim is also a separate matter. Under La. R.S. 22:1290, a settlement under a vehicle liability policy for a claim against an insured for damage to or destruction of property owned by another person is not treated as an admission of liability on any other claim from the same accident.

Write down who called, when they called, and what was said. If you need more time to review a request, you can say so and ask for it in writing.

Not sure what your next step is?

Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Frequently Asked Questions About Medical Records and Car Accident Claims

Do insurance companies get access to medical records?

Usually, access comes through a signed authorization or release. What they can see is set by what you sign.

Should I tell my insurance company about an accident?

Yes, you should usually give your own insurer prompt notice of the crash. A detailed recorded statement is a separate step.

Can I ask the insurer to narrow a records request?

Yes. Ask in writing, and keep a copy of your request and any new form.

Can a lawyer review a medical authorization before I sign it?

Yes. A lawyer can review the provider list, the date range, and the record types with you.

Can the insurance company contact my doctors directly?

The answer turns on what you have signed. Each form states which providers and records it permits.

A black and white photo of a wrecked car with heavy damage on an urban street.

Talk With Przemek Lubecki About a Records Request After Your Crash

If you have a records request or form in hand after a car crash, you do not have to work out what it reaches alone. Przemek Lubecki is the responsible lawyer for this page. He is a trial lawyer, and he is licensed to practice law in Louisiana.

The firm’s office is in New Orleans. You can call 855-LUBECKI (Office in New Orleans). The firm represents people in Orleans Parish, Jefferson Parish, the New Orleans metro, and across Louisiana.

The first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue. The firm may associate or refer a case to other law firms where a matter calls for it.

Bring the request letter, the form, and your timeline. A conversation can help you see what the request reaches before you decide what to send. To start, request a free case evaluation.

Attorney advertising. The information on this page is general information, not legal advice; reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with American Trial Lawyer, LLC. Attorney responsible for this content – Przemek Lubecki, licensed in Louisiana and Illinois; office at 414 12th Street, New Orleans, LA 70124. You may be responsible for case costs and expenses in addition to the attorney fee. We may associate with, or refer your case to, other law firms; you will be told in writing before that happens.

Read before you sign

Review any medical records authorization or insurance release before you sign it. Ask what information it covers and who will receive it. If you are unsure, contact our office before signing anything.

Questions to ask before you sign

Read the full authorization

Check which providers, dates and types of records the form names. Broad forms can reach far more of your history than you expect.

Ask what is being requested

Find out who is asking for your records and why. A clear written request makes it easier to decide what to share.

Keep copies of everything

Save copies of any forms, letters and records you send or receive so you have a complete record of what was shared.

Pause before a recorded statement

Talk with a lawyer before giving a recorded statement about your injuries or medical care, especially while you are still treating.

Why start the conversation with us

Trial lawyers who listen

We take time to understand your injuries, your medical care and what the records may show.

Clear answers on your records

We explain what a release covers in plain language so you can decide what to sign.

Guidance from Przemek Lubecki

Przemek Lubecki is the responsible lawyer for this page and leads our New Orleans office.

Free, confidential first consultation

Your first consultation is free, confidential and comes with no obligation to continue.

Talk with Przemek Lubecki at our New Orleans office about your records and your crash.

Related practice areas

Call Now — Free Consultation (855) 582-3254